“Sometimes you have to let someone fall so they can rise.”

To me, this sounds both sufficiently generic and unhelpful enough that it could come from a Hallmark card or a bad self-help book.

This is, unfortunately, the sort of guidance caregivers often receive. It’s vague and aspirational. But it doesn’t address the real complexity of giving care or tell you much about what to do or how to act. It doesn’t tell you how to manage all the emotions that come along with feeling responsible for the safety of a loved one who, on that day or in that year, really doesn’t want your help.

I am not a caregiving expert, if such a thing exists. But I was my mother’s caregiver and, after much working through of emotions on all sides, ultimately found a resolution that is imperfect but, unlike a Hallmark card, is at least specific and concrete.

Now my mother and I have a running joke.

I simply say “you can fall, just don’t do it on my watch.”

That’s not actually the suggestion.

But it is the result — the ability to joke about the overwhelming fear that lived in my thoughts. As well as the anticipatory guilt, the lurking question of “if she falls, will it be my fault?”

For me, getting here required me to accept that although my mother had physical limitations, she was still a mentally competent adult who was capable of evaluating risk and reward for herself.

I also had to recognize that, after a lifetime of walking, it’s not easy to accept that walking may not be worth the risk.

In retrospect, some testing of the limits is a natural and understandable — maybe even necessary — response.

The issue we were grappling with, even if we didn’t name it as such, was autonomy — my mother’s right to make her own judgment calls. And that is something virtually no one willingly gives up.

Autonomy — my mother’s right to make her own judgment calls — is something virtually no one willingly gives up.

Which sounds right intellectually, but doesn’t help when you are awake in bed listening for any sound of a fall.

(Luckily there wasn’t a question of my mother’s mental capacity, and I recognize that raises a whole different set of issues I’m not addressing here.)

So my mother and I had to have a talk.

The precise words are unnecessary, but these are the issues we discussed:

  • Whether she understood the risks to herself if she fell (yes).
  • Did she understand the potential consequences to others if she fell (yes).
  • Did she feel like she could make a reasoned decision about the risks and rewards involved in any specific decision about whether to walk (also yes).

I heard her and she heard my concerns too — and I was able to (mostly) let it go.

Did I still feel anxiety and fear? Yes.

But these emotions no longer overwhelmed me in quite the same way.

And importantly, my mother was given what I suspect was the most important thing all along — my acknowledgment that this was her decision to make.

Is this a perfect answer? No.

But as a caregiver, the best we can do is often as perfect as it gets.

pursueyourpink · By Paula