I wrote my marriage vows. I sent them to my fiancé and he said that they were perfect, that the others in the subway must be wondering why he was crying.
And that was that. What I should have considered, though, was how quickly he declared them perfect. I had spent weeks writing them, thinking through each promise that I was committing myself to. These are the words I wrote:
I make these vows to the person you are today, and the person you will become tomorrow. I commit myself to the life we have today and the life we will create together tomorrow.
With all of me, I will love and cherish all of you, valuing in equal measure your perfections and imperfections, as you do mine. I will be your partner in all things, supporting you in times of happiness and of sadness, in sickness and health, in failure and triumph. I will dream with you, celebrate with you, laugh with you and cry with you. There is no challenge you will face alone because I will face it with you. All that I have to give, I give to you.
With these vows, I choose you as my person — my love, my life, and my home — today and always.
(Yes, it did hurt to write those words again.)
The words I struggled with the most were “and the person you will become tomorrow.” At 44, I was old enough to know that those words were perhaps the most important and the most scary.
You don’t know who your spouse will be in a year, much less thirty years. What if you don’t like that person very much? What if they become someone you don’t know how to live with? What if they become someone you just can’t live with?
But that, in my view, is exactly how it should work with vows — you should struggle with them. You should think through whether you are in fact capable of living up to them when life goes in a direction you never could have anticipated, when the impossible somehow is not only possible but very, very real.
Most of us spend enormous amounts of time planning our weddings. Flowers, food, invitations, and of course the dress. As we should.
But in truth, after the party is over, there is only one thing that will be part of your life forever (hopefully). And that is the vows.
I made a mistake with the vows. I wrote them and then simply accepted that my soon-to-be spouse loved them too. In retrospect, we should have sat down together and talked through each sentence. Imagined the worst-case scenario. And then decided, together, whether we each knew without a doubt that we had the capacity to live up to them, for better or for worse.
I happen to believe marriage is sacrosanct and your vows are the most important promises you will make in your life.
So much so, in fact, that when lies and infidelity and me being informed that I had unknowingly married a sociopath became part of my marriage, I still struggled with leaving. Because of those vows. I knew that I wouldn’t leave my husband for some other mental disease — depression or even schizophrenia — so how could I justify leaving for a mental disease of any other sort? Hadn’t I made the vows to “the person you will become tomorrow,” whoever that was?
It wasn’t until someone smarter and more insightful than me observed something that I had not thought of. They said: “Vows are a contract between two people. He already broke the contract, you don’t have the obligation to live up to it anymore.”
And that gave me the freedom to no longer be haunted by the worry that somehow I was failing by not living up to the words that I saw as forever promises, never to be breached.
The lesson I take from all of it, though, is that forever promises should never be made without a serious heart-to-heart about what those words mean. If you are lucky, both you and your spouse will do this — despite how hard it may be — because you each intend to treat them as the forever promises they should be.
