pursueyourpink No. 13

The Sunday edition

il filo

the thread

Seven original stories, every Sunday — on the topics worth your time and the questions your other sources haven’t thought to ask yet.

No. 13Seven storiesBy Paula Crane
A couple in motion in their kitchen

This week

Behind Our Door

On marriage as we see it, marriage as it is lived, and the assumptions we make in between.

IEditor’s Note

Behind Our Door

What it means to look at a marriage from outside the door — and what we still can’t know.

I have a quip that I routinely make: if you think someone has a normal family, you don’t know their family very well. I think I came up with that myself. Maybe I heard it somewhere I no longer remember.

No matter. Let’s extend the point.

If you think a marriage is perfect, or even always pleasant, the thing you actually know is that you are not one of the people in it.

Because there is no perfect marriage, and even disastrous marriages are rarely disastrous in precisely the same way every moment of every day. There are millions upon millions of marriages that exist behind closed doors, where what you would see if you were let in would depend on the day. Or even the decade.

Some happy, some miserable. Some romantic, some transactional. Some sexless, some with sex that requires a surprising number of accoutrements.

And there isn’t a single Facebook photo, Instagram post or even video that opens the door to us all day and all night. I believe we can all agree that even shows that call themselves “reality TV” have little to do with actual reality.

But let’s imagine some new technology — the one AI will somehow create despite our wishes as part of its destroy-humanity strategy — lets us see behind the door. We will see what we see and make a judgment. We will know how we feel about it.

And that’s about it.

Maybe it looks like perfection to us. Our version of perfection, that is. Maybe it looks lonely, strange, enviable, cold, loving or completely incomprehensible.

But we still won’t know how the two people behind the door feel about it.

Because seeing a marriage is not living it.

It is with that premise that this edition of il filo is written. It is not a guide, tutorial or self-help tool of any sort, at least not the way we usually think of such things.

Because seeing a marriage is not living it.

What it tries to do instead is explore, as much as possible, what is behind various doors at this moment in time. How we are living marriage, how we feel about it, what it means to us and what significance it has in our lives. How it looks different from 50 years ago, 500 years ago, and across an ocean or two. And how, in some ways, it looks exactly the same.

(And essential stuff, of course, like the popularity of The Joy of Sex over time.)

Permit me a brief aside, because I like to be transparent when it’s relevant. For those of you who have read about my own marital past, you may find it surprising that I chose this topic despite, rather than because of, my experience with marriage.

My failed marriage has not diminished my sense of the singular miracle of marriage — of its ability to be the place where we discover our best selves, the solid ground under our feet in a world that keeps shifting around us.

If you are married, there was a day in your past when someone looked at you and decided, of all the billions of people on this Earth, you are the one person I want to walk this path with. To my mind, there are few greater compliments anyone can give or we can ever receive.

And I of course know that this compliment does not mean you ended up sharing a life together. Life and love are complicated that way. For those who did, it is probably not because the romance of that day simply continued, uninterrupted, through every day that followed. It is because you struggled. You worked at it. You found ways to manage the blows to your heart. You adjusted, eventually, to changes in your partner you did not expect and perhaps did not want and, to this day, don’t particularly like.

Marriage isn’t easy. No way around it.

Yet sometimes, somehow, two people remain.

There is something extraordinary in that. Not because the ugliness disappears, but because something can be built through it.

Not all marriages merit the effort. A destructive marriage is destructive. I lived one, and I know the consequences. A marriage can bring out your best self. It can also destroy any sense of yourself.

But I still believe marriage is worth thinking about and talking about. So this issue is simply a glimpse behind the closed door, to the extent such a glimpse is available to us.

You might reasonably wonder what the purpose of that glimpse is.

Our marriages live within a context. Family, friends, professional colleagues. Authors, therapists, influencers. Most have something to say about marriage and may have something to say about yours. Sometimes we are the ones with opinions about a marriage that isn’t ours.

The value of looking at what happens behind other closed doors is to become a little less certain that the standard visible from outside the door is the right one. Because, as it turns out, we are often not very good at interpreting marriage as it is presented to us.

At the end of the day, there are two people behind the door — and it is their experience of the marriage that counts.

IIMarriage & History

Marriage Then and Now, Marriage Here & There

Choice, arrangement, law, and the birds who require proof before they build the nest.

We tend to talk about marriage as though everyone knows what we mean. Two people fall in love. They marry. They promise to be there for better or for worse. They establish a home, perhaps have children, and, if all goes according to plan, grow old together and enjoy matching rocking chairs.

That is certainly a marriage. It is just not the definition of marriage.

Travel far enough geographically, historically or culturally and almost every part of that description becomes questionable or even clearly wrong.

Our first assumption: you choose the person you marry.

But for much of human history, and continuing in some cultures today, marriage was too important to be left to mere attraction and romance. A marriage might join families, consolidate property, preserve wealth, create political alliances, provide labor, determine inheritance and establish permanent relationships well beyond two individuals.

Love might develop within the marriage. Or not. Either way, it was not the only reason for the marriage.

Today, we assume something very different. Beginning particularly in the eighteenth century, Western culture increasingly embraced the idea that the people getting married should choose one another, and that mutual affection should be an important reason for doing it.

And family participation in choosing a spouse has never disappeared once we look beyond our borders.

India may be the example most familiar to Americans, although even there the phrase “arranged marriage” does not have a single definition. It can describe everything from parents identifying the spouse to a collaborative process in which parents introduce, screen or recommend potential partners while the people marrying retain the final choice.

From our perspective, these practices may feel archaic and fundamentally inappropriate.

The view from behind the door is more complicated.

Some people actively prefer the system exactly as it is. Recent research among middle-class young Indians found that many regarded arranged marriage as the safer option. Parental participation meant that two families, rather than simply two individuals, had invested in the marriage and might help support it when difficulties arose.

(Those of us enduring adult dating may now be more sympathetic to the benefits of arranged marriage than we once imagined.)

Studies comparing arranged and self-selected marriages also produce results that may surprise us. Some have found no meaningful difference in marital satisfaction, commitment or romantic love between the two.

That does not make arranged marriage inherently better, and I will risk being deemed biased or parochial to assert that I object to arrangements that deny any meaningful choice.

But this does expose another assumption we make from outside the door.

We may look at a marriage and think: I would never allow my parents to choose my husband.

The person behind the door may be thinking: why would I make the most important choice of my life without asking the people who know me best to help?

Other assumptions that we see as obvious are similarly contextual.

A couple sharing breakfast on a balcony

Under our laws, we can have only one spouse. Our actual lives are occasionally different. Plural families continue to exist, particularly among some fundamentalist religious communities, despite the fact that a person cannot legally be married to more than one spouse at a time.

And then there is the question of who you can marry, parental consent or not.

Until remarkably recently in the United States, the law answered that question according to race and sex. Interracial couples were still prohibited from marrying in some states until 1967. Same-sex marriage was not constitutionally protected nationwide until 2015.

Look beyond the United States and the boundaries change again. Same-sex marriage is now legal in dozens of countries, but most countries still do not permit it. Some cultures encourage marriage between relatives whom American families might regard as obviously off-limits. Cousin marriage remains common across parts of the Middle East, North Africa and South Asia, and even jurisdictions within the United States disagree about whether first cousins may marry.

Apparently even the question “Who is an appropriate person for me to marry?” has never had a universal answer.

And then there are the birds.

Birds are famous for pair-bonding, and there is a decidedly practical explanation for much of it.

Raising a baby bird can be an enormous amount of work.

Eggs need incubation and protection. Helpless chicks need repeated feeding. In most bird species, parental care is therefore a two-bird enterprise. A pair-bonded male and female share care in roughly four out of five bird species.

Some bird species even incorporate a rather practical demonstration of future husband material into courtship.

The male brings the female food. Repeatedly. It’s called courtship feeding.

(For the record, I think human females should develop some similar culling process.)

Courtship feeding can provide nutrition, strengthen the pair bond and give the female information about something quite important: whether the prospective father can actually acquire food and, most importantly, whether he is willing to keep doing it.

Before entrusting him with the nest, in other words, she may require evidence that he will show up with dinner.

There is something wonderfully familiar about that. Two things do seem true. First, we are — perhaps surprisingly — remarkably committed to marriage as an institution. Second, we have allowed for remarkable variation in how we marry, why we marry and who we can marry.

Before entrusting him with the nest, in other words, she may require evidence that he will show up with dinner.

The durability of marriage may come from our having finally discovered its correct form.

But maybe it comes from the institution’s extraordinary ability to survive — and even thrive — through endless variations of itself. That adaptability may help explain its continued prominence in a world in which marriage is no longer necessary for many of the things it once provided.

So this is the context when we look at somebody else’s marriage from outside the door. What seems obviously right, wrong or simply strange to us may look quite different to the people actually living behind it.

Maybe they need our perspective. Maybe we have no idea what’s really going on.

Either way, it’s worth considering what we truly know — and what we merely assume — about the marriage behind the door.

IIIThe Marriage Itself

The Two That Count

Why no outsider — expert, sister, or influencer — gets to set the standard for your marriage.

Most of us got married surrounded by people we loved, people we liked and perhaps even a few people we didn’t know particularly well.

But when we said “I do” — for better or for worse — we said the words to one person. And that person said the same words back to us.

The event was shared. The words were not.

Except between the two people that count.

The challenge of marriage is that there is no guidebook. Well, there are thousands of books that call themselves guidebooks, which may be part of the problem.

There isn’t even a definition that is particularly useful. Merriam-Webster defines marriage as “the state of being united as spouses in a contractual relationship recognized by law.” That is accurate. Also entirely useless when one of you is furious and the other one has no idea why.

It doesn’t tell you what to do after the first real hurt. Or the fiftieth. It doesn’t tell you how much compromise is loving and how much is losing yourself. It doesn’t tell you whether sleeping in separate bedrooms is evidence of trouble or simply evidence that one of you snores. It doesn’t tell you how a marriage should change when the people inside it change and one or both of you isn’t particularly fond of the person they ended up with.

To my mind, though, the absence of a useful guidebook is also what allows for the beauty, brilliance and rather extraordinary miracle of a marriage that works.

Because marriage may be common. A marriage that continues to sustain and nurture two people as they change over decades is far less so.

Two people begin with separate histories, separate families, separate fears, ambitions, habits, expectations and peculiarities. Somehow, over time, they create a third thing: a we.

That particular we has never existed before them and will never exist again.

And no one standing outside it can completely understand it.

I think we have established that across history, cultures and families, marriage has taken wildly different forms. Even within our own culture, we cannot seem to agree on what a “good marriage” looks like.

Nevertheless, an enormous industry would like to tell us.

There are books about the five things happy couples do and the seven things unhappy couples don’t. There are experts explaining how often we should have sex, how we should divide money, how we should fight, how much independence we should maintain and what our love language means for the person we share the bed with.

Some of this may be enormously useful. Some of it may be complete gibberish.

In both cases I sometimes wonder about the premise underneath it. How did any one author look across millions of marriages and determine what yours should look like?

And, for that matter, how did your sister? Or your best friend?

Because the uncomfortable truth is that we know remarkably little about other people’s marriages.

We know what they tell us. We know what we see. We know how they behave at dinner, on vacation and in photographs. We may know about the fights one spouse reports to us, while knowing nothing about the conversations the other spouse would describe.

A couple asleep, entangled, in bed

And other people know exactly that much about ours.

Which becomes increasingly important after 20 or 30 years.

By then, a marriage has accumulated its own language. Its own private compromises. Its own jokes and its own injuries.

Perhaps even separate bedrooms. Or separate vacations. Perhaps almost no separate anything at all.

One couple might look at another and think, I could never live like that.

That’s why it’s good they don’t have to.

In truth, there is no universal definition of a good marriage. There may not even be one particularly useful definition of a bad one beyond circumstances involving abuse, fear or coercion, where the judgment cannot simply be left behind a closed door.

But for the enormous territory between those boundaries, I think we allow outsiders too much space in our heads, and sometimes give ourselves too much permission to insert ourselves into something we don’t particularly understand.

So here is my contribution to the thousands of opinions already available on the subject, which I acknowledge may carry considerably less weight with you than your sister’s: What matters most is not whether your marriage looks like something someone — or even millions of someones — has declared to be good.

What matters is whether the two people living it believe it is good.

Or perhaps, during certain months or even years, good enough. And whether, when it isn’t, they still believe there is something there worth finding their way back to.

Family, friends, Instagram, self-help books, counselors and influencers of every variety can offer perspective. Sometimes enormously valuable perspective. They can ask questions we have avoided asking ourselves. They can see things we cannot. They can help us understand what is happening inside our own homes.

But opinion is different from ownership.

Until the influencer wakes up in your bed, lives through your Tuesday afternoons, knows what happened twenty-three years ago and understands why the seemingly insignificant thing your husband did this morning meant everything to you, she does not get to establish the standard against which you judge your marriage.

But opinion is different from ownership.

There are two people inside it.

Two people who know what happens after the dinner party ends and the front door closes.

They know what the silence means. They know when the teasing is affectionate and when there is something sharper underneath it. They know whether independence feels comfortable or lonely, and why one of them stayed when everyone else thought she should leave.

Two people who live behind the door.

The rest of us may be invited to the wedding. We may even be invited into parts of the marriage. We see what is visible outside the door and what one or both spouses choose to tell us about what happens behind it.

But there are still only two people who said the words. And, ultimately, those are the two that count.

IVData & Fidelity

What Matters to Virtually Every Two?

Fifty years of data on faithfulness, housework and children — and what “faithful” even means now.

Look back fifty years and you imagine a world in which marriages looked much more alike than the differences we see today.

But recall that fifty years ago interracial marriages and same sex marriages did not yet have constitutional protection. Who could marry has, unquestionably, changed.

What Americans thought mattered once they did marry changed much less.

In 1990, Americans were asked to rate nine things commonly associated with a successful marriage. Seventeen years later, Pew asked essentially the same questions again. The results are striking less for how much they changed than for how much they did not.

Faithfulness was considered “very important” by 93 percent of Americans in 1990.

In 2007, it was still 93 percent.

A happy sexual relationship went from 67 percent to 70 percent. Shared interests, adequate income, good housing and shared religious beliefs moved comparatively little as well.

So your mother and you — or your father and your brother — might have very different ideas about what a marriage should look like from the outside. But on many of the things that matter inside it, generations have been remarkably consistent.

There are, however, two conspicuous exceptions.

Children became much less central to Americans’ idea of a successful marriage. In 1990, 65 percent said having children was very important to marital success. By 2007, only 41 percent did. Children had fallen from third on the list of nine ingredients to eighth.

Housework traveled almost precisely in the opposite direction. In 1990, 47 percent considered sharing household chores very important to a successful marriage. By 2007, 62 percent did. Pew found the increase across men and women, married and unmarried people, and younger and older adults.

Our actual choices moved in the same general direction as our attitudes about children. Census data show that ever-married women ages 40 to 44 had, on average, roughly 3.2 children by that age in 1976. By 2024, the figure was about 2.1.

Marriage, in other words, became somewhat less about producing a family and somewhat more about managing the life the two people inside it were building together.

And yet faithfulness remained sitting there at the top.

That is particularly interesting because almost everything surrounding sex changed.

Americans became dramatically more accepting of sex outside marriage — provided, importantly, that neither participant was married to someone else. In 2001, just over half of Americans considered sex between an unmarried man and woman morally acceptable. By the early 2020s, roughly three-quarters did.

Acceptance of an affair by a married person, by contrast, barely moved at all.

Perhaps an even better illustration of how radically the sexual landscape is illustrated by that book I keep mentioning. Yes, I am once again referring to The Joy of Sex.

(I found my parent’s copy at ten and perhaps that explains some things).

Alex Comfort’s The Joy of Sex was published in 1972. It became a phenomenon, spending eleven weeks at number one on The New York Times bestseller list and more than seventy weeks in the top five. It ultimately sold millions of copies worldwide.

For a generation of readers, the extraordinary thing about the book was not simply what it said. It was that the information was suddenly available at all. When The Joy of Sex was substantially rewritten for a new edition in 2008, the world into which it arrived was almost unrecognizable. The new version added everything from cybersex to sex toys and reflected decades of new research. But by then, anyone with an Internet connection had access to vastly more information about sex than Alex Comfort could ever have fit between two covers.

The original had arrived in a culture where frank sexual information was difficult to obtain. The new edition arrived in a world already saturated with it.

We became more knowledgeable about sex.

We became more comfortable talking about sex.

We became far more accepting of sex before marriage.

We even became less convinced that marriage needed children.

But we did not become noticeably more accepting of having sex with someone else once we were married.

Which brings us to the more complicated question.

What, Exactly, Do We Mean by Faithful?

Fifty years ago, “faithful” had a somewhat narrower public meaning.

That does not mean emotional infidelity did not exist. Surely it did. But research on infidelity historically focused largely on whether a married person had engaged in sexual relations with someone other than his or her spouse. Emotional affairs, sexting, cybersex, pornography, online relationships and the assorted possibilities created by a device we now carry everywhere were either not systematically measured or did not yet exist.

Today, researchers identify a much broader spectrum of behavior that may — or may not — constitute infidelity.

And, as it turns out, our opinions vary not only according to the conduct itself, but according to the context in which it occurs. Sex remains the clearest boundary. Romantic kissing is not far behind. But move away from physical sexual conduct and consensus begins to unravel.

In one recent national survey, 59 percent of Americans said emotional involvement with another person was always cheating, while another 25 percent said it was sometimes cheating. Fifty-six percent said flirtatious messages were always cheating; another 26 percent said sometimes. Maintaining an online dating profile was always cheating to 60 percent and sometimes cheating to another 23 percent.

Then it gets even murkier.

Only 36 percent said having dinner with a friend or colleague to whom you are attracted was always cheating. Thirty-eight percent said sometimes.

Twenty-eight percent considered watching pornography without your partner always cheating. Half said it was never cheating.

Following an ex on social media? Twenty-one percent always cheating, 36 percent sometimes and 44 percent never.

Apparently, fidelity is one of those things about which we agree strongly until someone asks us to define it.

Context matters too.

Apparently, fidelity is one of those things about which we agree strongly until someone asks us to define it.

Large experimental studies in which researchers alter the circumstances surrounding potentially unfaithful behavior find that emotional involvement, duration and erotic online communication all affect whether people characterize behavior as infidelity. Sexual intercourse tends to be judged unfaithful regardless of the surrounding circumstances. But when the physical conduct becomes less explicit — kissing, hugging or no physical contact at all — the rest of the story matters much more.

Indeed, conduct involving no physical contact can still be judged infidelity when it combines emotional involvement with erotic communication.

Secrecy appears to matter independently as well. In another American survey, 80 percent of respondents considered lying to a partner about spending time with someone else cheating. Nearly three-quarters considered developing an intense emotional attachment to someone else cheating.

So the line is not simply between sex and no sex.

We appear to care about what happened, no surprise there. But we also want to know why it happened, how long it continued, how emotionally intimate it became and whether someone was trying to keep it hidden.

What becomes clear is that my definition of infidelity likely varies from yours. And yours likely varies from your sister’s, your neighbor’s and — by far most importantly — potentially your spouse’s.

Which makes the “two that count” paramount.

Fifty years ago, two people engaged to be married did not need to discuss their respective views on sexting, maintaining an online dating profile or whether pornography viewed alone constitutes infidelity.

Today they might.

The sheer range of opinions across the population establishes that, outside the clearest cases, there is no universally shared boundary separating faithful from unfaithful behavior.

That does not mean anything goes.

It means the two people inside the marriage have to decide what goes in their marriage.

They may not — and quite likely will not — enter that conversation with precisely the same views. One person may see an intimate friendship as entirely innocent while the other experiences it as profoundly threatening. One may consider pornography irrelevant to fidelity while the other considers secrecy surrounding it a betrayal. One may believe flirtation ends when the conversation ends. The other may believe the boundary was crossed much earlier.

Perhaps the important question is therefore not whether two people begin with identical rules. It is whether they can create rules together.

There is substantial marriage research supporting the importance of precisely that process. Researchers studying successful couples repeatedly find that healthy relationships are characterized not by the absence of disagreement, but by the willingness of each partner to be influenced by the other — to take the other’s feelings, needs and point of view seriously even when they are not identical to one’s own.

John Gottman has called this “accepting influence.” Other relationship researchers use the term “partner responsiveness”: the sense that your partner understands you, cares about you and appreciates what matters to you.

Even the language successful couples use provides a clue. Research on middle-aged and older couples has found that spouses who use more we, us and our language during disagreements show more positive emotional behavior and less physiological stress than couples whose language emphasizes I, me and you. Older couples, interestingly, demonstrate even more of this “we-ness.”

Perhaps fidelity boundaries work the same way.

The question cannot simply be: Do I think this behavior is acceptable?

In a marriage there is another question:

What does this behavior mean to us?

A conversation that produces an agreement both people can live with — and then an agreement both people honor — requires precisely the sort of give and take that marriage itself seems to require.

Not because one spouse automatically gets to impose his or her rule on the other.

But because being part of a we sometimes means allowing what matters deeply to the other person to matter to you too.

VReading the Proxies

What We See — And What We Think It Tells Us

Arguing, never arguing, separating, staying: why the visible proxies mislead us.

Most of us have a friend who tells us she is getting divorced and we are shocked. We thought her marriage was perfect. They never argued. She never complained. They seemed happy every time we saw them.

We may also know the couple we shake our heads at. They are always disagreeing about something. She routinely tells you he drives her up a wall. Perhaps you have wondered, more than once, why they are still married.

Whatever we saw, it probably told us less than we thought it did.

This is partly because the proxies we use to evaluate a marriage as good or bad are considerably less reliable than we assume. Sometimes they tell us something important. Sometimes they tell us almost nothing. The problem is that, from outside the door, we rarely know which is which.

The first proxy we tend to misinterpret is disagreement itself.

By now, you have probably heard, whether in passing or because you read a whole book on the topic, that marital arguments are not necessarily bad for a marriage. That has become sufficiently conventional wisdom that saying “healthy couples fight” hardly qualifies as insight anymore.

The research is actually more interesting than the slogan.

In longitudinal work by John Gottman and colleagues, disagreement and even exchanges of anger were associated with unhappiness at the time they occurred but, in some couples, predicted improvement in marital satisfaction over the following years. Other behaviors — defensiveness, withdrawal and the inability to recover from conflict — were more troubling.

In other words, the argument was not necessarily the important part.

What happened during it, and what happened afterward, mattered more.

One study found that how couples behaved after a conflict — when they were asked to shift into a more positive conversation — predicted later marital outcomes even better than the conflict discussion itself.

This probably makes intuitive sense once you think about your own arguments. The difference between a fight that leaves you furious for three days and one that somehow ends with somebody making the other person laugh is not the fact that there was a fight.

And successful marriages apparently do not require couples to resolve all of their disagreements either.

Gottman and Robert Levenson found that couples returned to essentially the same problems again and again. Their research produced the frequently cited estimate that roughly 69 percent of marital conflicts are “perpetual” — rooted in enduring differences between the people involved rather than problems that can simply be solved.

Some couples never reach the compromise we tend to assume a successful marriage requires.

He still wants to spend every vacation hiking. She still believes a vacation should involve room service.

Twenty-five years later, neither has persuaded the other.

The marriage may nevertheless be perfectly fine.

The real question becomes what the couple does with a disagreement that is apparently going nowhere. Can they keep having it without turning the disagreement into contempt for the person on the other side of it? Can they occasionally laugh about the absurdity of still having the same argument after twenty-five years?

Sometimes the disagreement simply becomes part of the marriage.

Then there is the opposite proxy: the couple that appears never to disagree at all.

Sometimes the disagreement simply becomes part of the marriage.

Anyone who has felt miserable and then gone to a dinner party, smiled, chatted and asked someone else how her children are probably understands the problem with relying too heavily on public behavior.

We do not bring everything outside the door.

Research on married couples suggests that spouses themselves observe different rules for conflict in public and private. When other people are present, couples place more emphasis on restraint and appearing rational. Behind the door, they are more likely to focus on actually resolving whatever they are arguing about.

So the couple who never disagrees in front of us may indeed rarely disagree.

Or they may simply believe that whatever is happening between them is none of our business.

The dinner party does not tell us which.

The way people talk about their spouses can mislead us too.

A woman may spend fifteen minutes describing the latest ridiculous thing her husband did and leave us wondering why she tolerates him. But researchers who have studied how spouses tell the story of their marriages find that the existence of complaints is less revealing than the larger story surrounding them.

In studies where couples were asked to describe how they met, why they married and what they had been through together, the marriages that remained intact were more likely to contain fondness, affection and a sense that difficulties were things “we” had gone through together. Couples whose marriages later ended were more likely to tell their histories through disappointment, negativity and separateness.

There is a meaningful difference between “He drives me absolutely crazy” said by someone who still plainly adores him and “He has always been selfish” said as the organizing principle of twenty years together.

From across the lunch table, we may not appreciate the difference.

And finally there is the proxy that seems impossible to misread: the marriage ends.

Surely that tells us something.

Usually it does.

The decision to separate after twenty or thirty years carries enough emotional, financial, familial and practical consequences that few people make it casually. But even here, the event we see from outside the door does not always tell us the final story.

Research following Americans who separated from a spouse after age 50 found that within ten years approximately 7 percent of women and 11 percent of men had reconciled with that spouse.

That is a minority. Most separated couples did not reunite.

But it is a large enough minority to remind us that even separation does not invariably mean that whatever existed between two people is finished.

Actual remarriage to a former spouse after a completed divorce appears to be much rarer. It happens nonetheless.

Perhaps that should not surprise us. Marriage is not necessarily linear. People leave. Sometimes they return. Sometimes the time apart clarifies why they left. Sometimes it clarifies why they want to go back.

And, of course, the reverse is also true.

The mere fact that two people remain married is remarkably poor evidence that what is happening behind the door is good.

A marriage certificate can tell us that a marriage exists.

It cannot tell us very much about what kind of marriage it is.

Which leaves us in an uncomfortable position when we try to judge someone else’s relationship.

We can see the argument. We can hear the complaint. We can notice that they never disagree in public. We can learn that they separated, or that despite everything they stayed.

Those facts are real.

It is what we think they prove that requires more caution.

VITherapy & Coercive Control

Couples Therapy Is Always the Right Answer From Outside the Door, But Not Behind It

Mixed agendas, discernment counseling, and telling ordinary conflict apart from coercive control.

When a friend tells us her marriage is in trouble, one piece of advice sounds almost unquestionably responsible.

Go to couples therapy.

And, indeed, it often is good advice. A large analysis of 58 studies involving more than 2,000 couples found significant improvements in relationship satisfaction following couples therapy, along with improvements in communication, emotional intimacy and partner behavior.

So, to be clear: this is not an argument against couples therapy. It is simply a caution that, from outside the door, we are not able to know that couples therapy is the right answer. The suggestion makes sense. But if our friend doesn’t follow the advice, we shouldn’t assume she is being unreasonable or lacks the sort of commitment that marriage requires.

Our advice assumes certain facts that we may not know from outside the door.

First, it assumes that our friend and her partner want to work on the same problem. That may not be true. Which, unsurprisingly, creates a problem.

“Mixed-agenda couples” are relationships in which one person is leaning toward ending the marriage while the other wants to save it. It’s not uncommon; research suggests that this dynamic may exist in nearly 40 percent of couples in clinical settings.

If one spouse arrives at therapy hoping to repair the marriage and the other arrives trying to decide whether to leave it, “work on the marriage” is not yet a shared goal.

That mismatch gave rise to something called discernment counseling. Its purpose is not initially to save the marriage. It is to determine what the two people actually want to do with it. In one study of 100 couples who entered discernment counseling, about half ultimately chose to undertake couples therapy in an effort to reconcile. Most of the others chose divorce.

So sometimes the first question is not “how do we fix this?”

It’s “do we both want to?”

Second, advice to go to couples therapy assumes that both people can participate safely and in good faith. This, unfortunately, isn’t always the case.

Where a relationship involves “coercive control” — a pattern of intimidation, domination, isolation or control rather than ordinary marital conflict (discussed in the il filo issue Locked Out) — experts caution that couples therapy can be inappropriate and may even create additional danger.

What is said in the therapist’s office can still have consequences once the couple gets home.

A related concept is the use of mental-health language itself as a weapon. Researchers have documented what they call “mental-health weaponization”: portraying a partner as crazy or unstable, using previous trauma against her or invoking a diagnosis to undermine her credibility.

The vocabulary of therapy can help a person express emotions they previously did not have the language for. But it can also sound remarkably authoritative when used by someone who has learned to apply it strategically.

Consider these statements:

“My therapist says you are projecting.”

“You are violating my boundary.”

“You’re triggered because of your childhood.”

Those statements may be entirely legitimate. They may also be manipulative nonsense.

Which brings us to one of the problems with the increasingly popular word “toxic.”

Sometimes we see behavior we dislike and describe the relationship itself as toxic. An ugly fight becomes evidence of a toxic marriage. Jealousy does. Withdrawal does. A selfish act does.

Sometimes those behaviors are part of something much more serious. Sometimes they are two people behaving badly. The word “toxic” is no longer just social-media shorthand. The APA Dictionary of Psychology now defines a toxic relationship around a pattern of harmful relational behavior, including coercive control, emotional manipulation, gaslighting, relational aggression, jealousy and abuse.

The important word may be pattern.

One cruel argument is not the same thing as a relationship organized around fear, domination or harm.

I suspect most of us have said things to our partners in the heat of the moment that we regret. I certainly have. But — and here I admit I am expressing my personal perspective only — I think one terrible moment usually tells us less about a person than what they do with it afterward. What they take from it, what they learn and whether they repeat it is, to my mind, much better evidence of who they are.

One cruel argument is not the same thing as a relationship organized around fear, domination or harm.

The distinction matters in both directions.

Calling ordinary marital conflict abusive does not make it so. But calling coercive control a “communication problem” does not make that so either.

Coercive control does not imply mutual responsibility. It is not a marital dynamic that both partners have to “work on.” We do not ask the spouse who is punched in the face to consider what they did to precipitate the abuse. The same standard should apply to coercive control.

From outside the door, “You two need therapy” can sound thoughtful, neutral and assuredly reasonable.

Behind the door, there may indeed be two people who need help learning how to talk to one another. A therapist may be exactly what the marriage needs.

But before we assume the solution from outside the door, it helps to remember that we may not know the problem.

Maybe we do. Maybe we don’t.

It is worth asking ourselves which.

VIILong Marriages

The Things We Mistake for Absence

What the quiet couple at the next table might actually be — and what we can’t tell from here.

We have all seen them. The older couple at the restaurant who barely says a word through dinner.

We may look across the room and think: God, I hope that never happens to us. I have. More than once.

Perhaps we should worry. Perhaps they have run out of things to say. Perhaps the toll of jobs, children, conflict and just time has squeezed any semblance of romance out of their relationship.

Maybe we should in fact work hard to make sure that doesn’t happen to our marriage. But maybe we are interpreting silence as something it’s not.

There is surprisingly little research that tells us what silence means inside a long marriage. Researchers measure conflict, affection, conversation, touch, sexual activity and marital satisfaction. Whether two people quietly finishing their entrées are happy has not been a research topic.

So we cannot claim that the silence of older couples is companionable. But research does suggest that marriage itself appears to change with age in ways that caution against reading more into silence than it may deserve.

In one study that followed long-married couples for 13 years, researchers brought them into the laboratory and had them discuss an area of disagreement. As the couples aged, belligerence, defensiveness and other negative emotional behavior declined. Humor, enthusiasm and validation increased.

The disagreements had not necessarily disappeared but the people having them had changed.

That finding also complicates another familiar assumption about long marriage: that romance slowly gives way to companionship and then, if things go reasonably well, to affectionate coexistence.

Sometimes it does. And, it seems to me, that is not an inherently bad thing. (I admit that this was not always my opinion. There is something about living a marriage filled with entirely too much drama that makes “peaceful coexistence” sound much more attractive than it once did. So take that comment for what it’s worth.)

But romantic love turns out to be much less confined to the newly married than popular culture would have us believe. In a random U.S. sample of married adults, 40 percent of people who had been married for more than ten years described themselves as “very intensely in love.”

Researchers have even looked inside the brain. In a small study of people married an average of more than 21 years who described themselves as intensely in love, seeing a photograph of their spouse activated parts of the brain’s reward system also associated with early romantic love.

Twenty years later, apparently, some brains still recognize the person and light up the same way.

What romance looks like by then may be harder for anyone outside the marriage to identify.

Twenty years later, apparently, some brains still recognize the person and light up the same way.

A couple sitting together, decades ago

We know what early romance looks like because it is almost impossible to miss. Absurdly long telephone conversations, plans made around another person’s availability and a general willingness to remain awake at hours we later come to regard as unreasonable. In my case, it included sending my partner every love song I could find on Spotify (there are a lot).

What romance looks like twenty or fifty years later isn’t quite so obvious. Affectionate touch is one example. In a national study of 953 older married couples, spouses who reported more shared affectionate touch subsequently reported greater relationship satisfaction, life satisfaction and mental well-being five years later — even when researchers accounted for sexual activity.

The touch need not lead to a bed. It may simply be a hand on a shoulder as one person passes the other in the kitchen.

Sex itself does not disappear either, although it changes. Studies of older married couples find enormous variation in sexual expression, from little activity to couples who remain highly sexually engaged. Among partnered women over 60 in one study, 59 percent reported having been sexually active during the preceding six months. Again, the view from outside the door tells us little about which couple is which.

I will not, however, impose a “happily ever after” ending on every couple. Life is not always a fairy tale, however much we may wish it were.

Silence is not always the comfort developed over decades. Sometimes it’s just silence.

Studies of older married adults find meaningful levels of loneliness even among people who have spouses. One study found moderate or strong emotional or social loneliness in roughly one-quarter to one-fifth of married adults ages 64 to 92. In another national study of older couples, poor marital quality was associated with greater loneliness, and good relationships with friends and relatives did not erase the effect.

So the quiet couple at dinner may be completely at ease. One of them may also be painfully lonely.

From our table, they can look exactly the same.

The performance of romance may become less obvious over time. The conversation may become less necessary. Two people can spend an evening doing completely different things three feet apart and experience that distance as comfort rather than neglect.

Or not.

Which takes us back to where we began.

A marriage is lived in details that outsiders rarely see. Life is made up of the small moments that happen behind the door. The joke that sounds rude to us may have a thirty-year history that makes both people laugh.

There are marriages that become lonely. There are marriages in which romance disappears. And there are marriages in which love is still there after decades, only quieter than it once was.

Only the two people behind the door truly know.

Further Reading

Research to dive into and books to read further.

Dive into the research

  • Pew Research Center — As Marriage and Parenthood Drift Apart

    A useful look at what Americans believe makes a successful marriage, including the remarkable stability of the importance placed on faithfulness and the changing importance of children and shared household responsibilities.

  • Buehlman, Gottman & Katz — The Oral History Interview

    Research examining how couples describe their own marriages — including fondness, negativity, disappointment and “we-ness” — and how those narratives relate to later marital stability.

  • Gottman & Krokoff — Marital Interaction and Satisfaction

    One of the studies complicating the conventional view that anger and disagreement themselves signal marital failure. Some conflict behaviors associated with unhappiness in the moment predicted later improvement, while defensiveness and withdrawal were more concerning.

  • Roddy et al. — Meta-analysis of Couple Therapy

    An analysis of 58 studies involving more than 2,000 couples finding substantial average gains in relationship satisfaction, communication, intimacy and partner behavior following couples therapy.

  • Mixed-Agenda Couples: Large-Scale Evidence

    Recent research suggesting that conflicting relationship agendas are not unusual, particularly among couples already seeking clinical help.

  • Trauma- and Violence-Informed Research on Couples Therapy

    Research distinguishing ordinary or situational couple conflict from coercive control, where couples therapy can be inappropriate or unsafe.

  • O’Leary, Acevedo, Aron et al. — Long-Term Romantic Love

    Research showing that intense romantic love can persist well beyond the early years of marriage, including among some people married for decades.

  • Affectionate Touch in Older Couples

    Research using data from 953 couples finding that affectionate touch predicted later relationship satisfaction and mental well-being independently of sexual activity.

  • Marriage and Loneliness in Later Life

    Research showing that marriage does not itself protect against loneliness and that the quality of the marital relationship remains highly relevant.

  • Sexual Expression in Older Couples

    Research showing wide variation in later-life sexuality, including couples who remain highly sexually engaged.

Explore further

  • BBC — How The Joy of Sex Was Illustrated

    A look at the challenge of illustrating The Joy of Sex at a moment when explicit sexual material was still something society generally kept behind the door.

  • The Gottman Institute

    The central repository for John and Julie Gottman’s books, articles, research explanations and relationship resources, and an accessible starting point for readers interested in much of the research discussed in this issue.

  • Esther Perel — The State of Affairs

    A thoughtful examination of infidelity that is more interested in what affairs reveal about relationships than in reducing betrayal to a single moral or therapeutic script.

  • Alain de Botton — The Course of Love

    A novel about what happens after romantic love succeeds in getting two people married — routine, disappointment, children, resentment, tenderness and the much less glamorous work of remaining together.

  • Anne Tyler — The Amateur Marriage

    A decades-long portrait of two people who love, injure and misunderstand one another, and of the enormous distance between what a marriage appears to be and what the people inside it experience.

  • Wallace Stegner — Crossing to Safety

    Two marriages observed across decades, particularly valuable for its treatment of loyalty, illness, friendship and the private bargains couples make over time.

  • Tayari Jones — An American Marriage

    A marriage radically altered by forces outside it, and a particularly good exploration of what commitment means once the original structure of a marriage has been disrupted.

  • Joan Didion — The Year of Magical Thinking

    Not a book about how to conduct a marriage, but an extraordinary retrospective portrait of one after death makes the shared life suddenly visible through its absence.

  • Arthur Aron — Work on Lasting Romantic Love

    Accessible discussions of the research behind long-term romantic attachment and why intense romantic love can persist decades into marriage.